Katiebabs is a self-proclaimed present day bluestocking with her head always in a book. She runs her own book blog called Babbling about Books and More!
How about we make it easy for these authors and not buy their books or mention them at all, so there are no reviews or word of mouth. How about that??
Please quit trying to lay down the law regarding what reviewers should or should not do whilst reviewing.
Firstly because it's not your place: you don't own or run the reviewing sites, so you don't get to make the rules. More importantly, though, is the fact that there will never be a consensus among you. I know that, because every time one author puts a rule forward, another author refutes it:
Some authors insist that it's unfair to write DNF reviews, while others mock readers who bother to finish a book they hate.
Some authors complain about the lack of text in reviews, while others complain about reviews being too long.
Some authors demand constructive criticism, and others feel harassed when it's offered.
And really what all this haranguing over reviews amounts to is: If a reader doesn't like your book, you want them to be quiet about it. That's all. That's the truth. The rules are just excuses. Possibly excuses you have told yourselves:
Not only is this behavior annoying to readers, but it's not a sustainable method for dealing with negative reviews, either. Sooner or later, someone will say something in a review that you cannot pigeonhole and dismiss. They'll point out something you can't deny.
Rather than coming up with excuses for why the review is wrong, you need to be fine with negative reviews regardless. They happen. If you're happy with your writing, and you're making enough sales to be satisfied, then who cares what your reviews say? But if you're not, then maybe the reviews could give you a clue as to why, and maybe you should pay attention, rather than closing your eyes and hoping they'll go away.
Not that reviews have to be constructive. That's more a bonus than anything. But that doesn't mean they can't provide insight into what you're doing wrong, just the same.
Think about it. Please? It's far easier to change what you are doing than to change what millions of readers might do.